Reviewer Form

Reviewers use this form to report on a manuscript. Complete every section and return it through the journal's online system or to editor@stanfordgroup.org.

Journal: Bio-QI Journal (Bio-QI)  |  ISSN: 3117-7336

Manuscript information

Manuscript ID; manuscript title; article type; reviewer name; date of review.

Reviewer declaration

  • I have no conflict of interest in reviewing this manuscript.
  • I will keep the manuscript and my review confidential.
  • My assessment is objective and my own.

Section A: General assessment

CriterionExcellentGoodFairPoor
Originality
Scientific significance
Relevance to the scope of the journal
Contribution to knowledge

Section B: Methodology and data quality

QuestionYesPartiallyNo
Is the study design appropriate?
Are the methods described clearly?
Is the statistical analysis sound?
Could the work be reproduced?

Comments:

Section C: Presentation and structure

QuestionYesPartiallyNo
Does the title reflect the content?
Is the abstract accurate and complete?
Are the figures and tables clear and necessary?
Are the references relevant and current?

Comments:

Section D: Ethical compliance

QuestionYesNoNot applicable
Does the study meet ethical standards, with approvals cited?
Was informed consent obtained where needed?
Are trial registration or data accession numbers given where they apply?
Are there concerns about plagiarism?

Comments:

Section E: Strengths and weaknesses

Major strengths:

Major limitations:

Section F: Comments for the authors

These comments are sent to the authors.

Section G: Confidential comments to the editor

These comments are seen by the editor only.

Section H: Recommendation

  • Accept
  • Accept with minor revisions
  • Major revisions
  • Reject

Reasons for the recommendation:

Final confirmation

Reviewer signature and date.

To apply to become a reviewer, see Join Our Reviewer Team.